Increasing Constraints by Higher Levels of Biological Organization

Feared by the bad, loved by the good,

Robin Hood! Robin Hood! Robin Hood!

                -Refrain from the theme of the television show The Adventures of Robin Hood

In the very interesting book by Raymond and Denis Noble, Understanding Living Systems, there is a figure (8.2 on page 128) that depicts a direction of increasing constraints by higher levels of organization on lower levels, and to my surprise, I agree.

However, these increasing constraints do not usually consist of threats of pain. In fact, the great majority of pain signals flow in the opposite direction, from lower systems to upper ones. It's Scotty in the engine room yelling to Captain Kirk in his Scottish brogue, "I'm givin' her all she's got, Captain!" (although he apparently never quite said that). When the increasing constraint does consist of threats of pain, say in a pack of wolves, the individual doing the threatening is very much at risk, direct or indirect.

In the case of human governance by the state, there is a combination of both threats of pain—inconvenience, imprisonment, or even death—and the absence of risk as the "deciders" are insulated by the many layers of bureaucrats and enforcers "just following orders" from the pain being inflicted.

Because of this isolation, we have stories of heroes like Robin Hood, who outsmarted the Sheriff of Nottingham and his boss, the evil King John, and returned money taken through onerous taxation to the helpless peasants. Modern political participants believe that democracy has created a return nerve pathway to signal pain to the rulers, but anyone can see that policies that are bad for the peasants are just as difficult to change as they were in Merry Olde England. Once the campaign is over, the elected politicians simply do as they like and their campaign utterances can only cause them real harm in the next election.

As a rollback of the state seems unlikely, the only remedy for this situation is the possibility of secession on the scale of the individual, possibly leading to a situation like what Chandran Kukathas advocates in The Liberal Archipelago. This remedy was eventually applied in the case of state religions with the happy result that religious wars and persecution, at least in western nations, have ceased. Let each person choose their property regime and method of bringing it to fruition, and let entrepreneurs respond to those choices.